Your credibility is the most important element of your case. Deceit is rampant in divorce cases, and judges have little patience for such behavior. If there is a weak point in your case, meet the problem head on. All people make mistakes, and you can describe an incident as a lapse of judgment under trying conditions.  If you are sincere and convincing, it will damage your case less than lying would. For an article about what not to do during your divorce, click here.

The importance of truthfulness holds true when the issue is infidelity within the marriage.  It is best to admit to obvious affairs and deal with the problem on the stand to take the punch out of your spouse’s argument about an affair.  That’s not to say that complete confession during the negotiation phase is optimal. Certainly, each case is different, but telling the truth to a judge in a straight forward and brief fashion at a trial can be much less damaging than ignoring the scenario and waiting for it to be raised by your spouse’s attorney, or having your spouse parade a series of witnesses of photographs through the court after you have not been truthful about a new relationship. 

Bud is an attorney who was on trial for divorce. He had been unhappy in his marriage to Janice for many years but had not had an affair. During the final months before separating, Bud fell in love with Samantha, a co–worker, and became sexually involved with her. He never told Janice about the relationship and his intent to marry his new partner, but he was pretty sure she suspected something since he was unwilling to consider counseling or reconciliation. At the trial, he readily admitted to being involved before Janice could accuse him, discussing his loneliness and the new happiness that Samantha breathed into his life. He depicted the new relationship as unfortunate (because it started before his marriage ended) but loving and positive, and expressed the importance to him that Janice not suffer needlessly for it. Despite the high degree of animosity between the couple, the judge believed Bud’s account and rendered the affair as inconsequential compared to the other issues in the divorce. 

Once you’ve admitted the relationship, photographs or Valentine’s cards lose their significance as evidence against you.  The judge probably doesn’t care much about them at all. However, if you lied, then the lie becomes a credibility issue that affects your entire case.

If you are tempted to lie at any point during your divorce remember that your spouse may have a photograph or document that proves your statement is untrue.  You could then be in the unenviable position of attempting to retract testimony that is undercut by the contents of a document, photograph, videotape, or tape recording. Once a judge decides you’re lying about one issue, all of your testimony becomes suspect. As a consequence, you may be punished in the property settlement or alimony aspects of your case. Click here for an article about perjury in divorce cases.

Lying under oath is perjury.  Perjury is a crime. Many judges refer perjury in divorce cases to the prosecutor’s office. Judges may also refer matters involving drugs, false tax returns, or other crimes. If these are issues in your case strongly consider settling with your spouse out of court rather than take the chance of facing criminal prosecution along with your divorce case.

If you are tempted to lie about a situation in your case, you speak with your lawyer in advance so that you can decide together the best way to handle it. No reputable lawyer will permit you to lie or will condone a suggestion to lie on the stand, but will assist you in a legal way to minimize any ill effects that you might experience because of the scenario that presents itself.

Excerpted from Your Divorce Advisor: A Lawyer and a Psychologist Guide You Through the Legal and Emotional Landscape of Divorce (Simon & Schuster/Fireside 2001). For more information: http://www.yourdivorceadvisor.com/.

For more information contact Peace Talks www.peace-talks.com 

(C) 2008  Peace Talks Mediation Services, Inc.